Customer Reviews
Men's Johnston & Murphy Aragon II - Black Deer/Antique Chestnut

On Sale $99.95
(26% off - was $135.00)

We're sorry -- no color of this style is currently available.

Back to Browsing  |  View Entire Brand

1 - 15 of 102 | Next >>

Sort By: Most Helpful | Least Helpful | Newest | Oldest | Highest Rated | Lowest Rated

Customer Reviews

Overall Customer Rating: (102 Reviews)
Shoe Size: 94% of people said that this shoe "Felt true to size"
Shoe Width: 85% of people said that this shoe "Felt true to width"

Write an online review

  • Classic everyday shoes March 15, 2013
    Reviewer: Tom from Los Angeles
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    Great looking everyday shoes. Very comfortable. Can be worn with or without socks. If you wear them without socks, however, the insoles tend to loosen and wrinkle after a few months. Sperry Gold Cup handles this well, with their deerskin inner linings, though Sperry doesn't make a shoe this good looking and the Gold Cups are a lot more expensive.
    Wears this shoe: Almost every day

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • 1 out of 2 people found the following review helpful: Great shoe. January 01, 2013
    Reviewer: Ben from Houston, TX
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    This is the second pair of this shoe my husband has bought. He says it is extremely comfortable and very versatile. It looks great with jeans as well as business casual. He can wear them with or without socks. They wear well, and he is very hard on shoes.
    Wears this shoe: Leisurewear and business casual

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • Wider than most narrow shoes Ive had. October 10, 2012
    Reviewer: Getting older by the minute from South Carolina
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt wider than marked
    I have to wear a narrow loafer to keep it from slipping and I didn't find this one to be as narrow as Bass and Florsheim shoes I have. I've compensated by wearing thicker socks which works well for me.The shoes look great and feel very comfortable. In hindsight I probably should have bought the 11-1/2 instead of the 12 but overall I'm very satisfied.
    Wears this shoe: Whenever a brown loafer will work with the outfit.

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • 0 out of 1 person found the following review helpful: Attractive shoe, comfortable well see how it wears September 13, 2012
    Reviewer: RussXE from Houston TX
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    These shoes were comfortable, I buy 1/2 size bigger to accomodate gel insoles and the fit fine. It takes a while to break loafers in but I'm wearing them regularly and they are softer and comfortable. Maybe not the quality I was expecting from J&M.
    Wears this shoe: Work

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • 1 out of 2 people found the following review helpful: Excellent shoe, quality, buy! June 17, 2012
    Reviewer: Anonymous from
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    This is the third pair of these shoes that I have ordered (one in each available color). I usually wear oher shoes, but found these shoes much more comfortable and of better quality.
    Wears this shoe: Daily

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • 1 out of 2 people found the following review helpful: EIGHT or MORE May 30, 2012
    Reviewer: John from Leawood, Kansas
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    This is at least the 8th pair of this shoe I have purchased. The first pair was at a Shoe Warehouse store. All others through Shoebuy. The shoes work great for me. They fit just right from the first time I put them on my feet until I replace them. Only complaint is that the inner lining usually comes loose while the rest of the shoe still looks and feels good.
    Wears this shoe: Both work and casual dress

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • 2 out of 2 people found the following review helpful: May 10, 2012
    Reviewer: Dave from Leesburg, VA
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    Wanted something for work and "play" and this shoe fit the bill. Very comfortable and goes well with dress slacks as well as jeans. You can't beat Johnston and Murphy for a quality shoe.
    Wears this shoe: Work and casual

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • Hope they dont stop making this shoe. March 14, 2012
    Reviewer: David H. from Maryland
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    Comfortable. True to size. Coordinates with most of my wardrobe.
    Wears this shoe: Dress casual office attire.

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • GDT February 13, 2012
    Reviewer: GDT, Jr. from Naashville, AR.
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    I am well pleased, the shoes fit and I can recomend them to any one.
    Wears this shoe: Any time is a right time.

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • Beautiful Shoe February 13, 2012
    Reviewer: David from Harrisonburg, VA
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    What's not to like? This shoe is an update of a classic...it is as beautiful as it is comfortable.
    Wears this shoe: Whenever I want to. They famously will go with anything!

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • Great purchase January 12, 2012
    Reviewer: Josh from Hueytown, Alabama
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    Really liked the look and feel of this shoe, can be worn with brown or black
    Wears this shoe: shoe is worn when dress casual attire is in order

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • Poitive November 11, 2011
    Reviewer: Retired Senior from Columbia, SC area
    Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    I like loafers and the black and brown give me something new and unique to the mix for my wardrobe.

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • Great Customer Service August 05, 2011
    Reviewer: Anonymous from New York, NY
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    Love the style, fit, price, and of course free shipping.J&M is one of my favorite shoe brands for style and fit.
    Wears this shoe: Casual outings with jeans or chinos.

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • 0 out of 1 person found the following review helpful: Good quality shoe May 03, 2011
    Reviewer: Stephan F. from Nashville
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    This is my third pair of this particular style. It is very comfortable and goes with casual pants and dress pants. Good quality.
    Wears this shoe: Weekends, after work, vacation

    Was this review helpful to you? 
  • 0 out of 1 person found the following review helpful: December 08, 2010
    Reviewer: Tom C. from Los angeles
    Shoe Size: Felt true to size Shoe Width: Felt true to width
    Good looking and comfortable shoes.
    Wears this shoe: Casual and work

    Was this review helpful to you? 
Return to product detail page 1 - 15 of 102 | Next >>